Every economy has two faces: the part that appears in budgets, tax returns, stock markets, and government statistics and another one which exists behind it that is far larger, quieter, and often more powerful. It is not printed in reports, yet it shapes prices, politics, and even people’s dreams. This is the shadow economy. It is the parallel system of unreported, untaxed, and illegal money that flows through societies like an invisible river of black money. The troubling question today is no longer whether this shadow exists, but whether it has grown so large that it now begins to distort and overpower the formal economy. What was once a hidden leak in the system now risks becoming the system itself.
The biggest contributor to this economy is tax evasion. Many of us don't know that only about 1.6% to 2% of Indians pay income tax! As a result, the government is unable to generate expected revenue through taxes, because of people evading taxes through loopholes like under-reporting of income, benami transactions, and round-tripping techniques. We need to understand that every rupee that is lost through tax evasion is a rupee stolen from building classrooms, hospitals, roads, research and development etc. Low public investment leads to low productivity further resulting in slow growth. Ironically enough, by definition, black money is the kind of money that the government is unaware of, but people in the government often understand its workings better than anyone else, and many even participate in it. A junior officer pays the one above him to secure his posting and that officer pays the one above him, creating a vertical chain of corruption.
The elite class hides their money, the middle class pays taxes honestly but gets fewer to no public services in return. Honest firms fall behind tax-evading counterparts and so formal job creation stagnates. The price of almost everything in the economy can be matched to your wallet as everything has become purchasable, from saving yourself from traffic challans to getting promotions and contracts. And things start to look really bad when the cost of two innocent lives come down to an essay to back an affluent teenager. In such cases the black economy acts as a shield for the wealthy people and thus a price tag is put on the life of a common man.
The shadow economy is a master at nourishing organised crime and somewhere threatens national security as illegal trade is practised like drugs, arms trafficking, or mining depending upon unaccounted cash flows. Mafias thrive through a three-way nexus between businessmen seeking shortcuts, politicians offering cover, and officials enabling illegal operations. As these networks expand, systems like Hawala channels grow stronger and ultimately become the connecting link to foreign criminal and extremist groups. What starts as local corruption can escalate into a national security risk if gone without surveillance.
As infamous as the shadow economy already is, it's not a big problem for society, at least not as big as normalising it. In popular culture the shadow economy is no longer portrayed as destructive, but rather stylised and aspirational. This cultural normalisation seeps into real life. A large section of youth aspiring for government jobs quietly sees public service not as a duty, but as access to stability, authority, and under-the-table income.
One of the most dangerous aspects of the shadow economy today is not secrecy, but acceptance. Black money has stopped feeling illegal and started feeling normal. From bribing a traffic policeman to avoid a challan, to paying in cash for land, to distributing money during elections... These acts no longer shock society. The shadow economy is not sustained only by criminals or elites. White-collar employees accepting cash components, professionals under-reporting income, businesses avoiding GST, consumers demanding “no-bill” discounts, this ordinary participation normalises illegality. The system survives because compliance has become selective and convenience now overrides ethics. Its impact on the environment is equally destructive. Illegal mining deteriorates landscapes, riverbeds, and ecosystems. Wildlife smuggling, timber theft, and unregulated construction projects damage biodiversity and violate environmental safeguards. These activities survive precisely because black money shields them from scrutiny.
The ever-present shadow of the ‘shadow’ economy stretches and contracts with policy, enforcement, and public attitude. Black money bends the shape of markets, and sectors that easily absorb black money get over-inflated like real estate, gold, luxury goods, and thus, prices become unfair for the layman. The shadow economy is not just a financial problem, rather a moral and institutional one. It quietly erodes trust, rewards dishonesty, and punishes those who try to play by the rules. When corruption becomes normal, legality starts to feel optional, and that is when a society begins to lose its spine. The greatest danger today is not that black money exists, but that people have learned to live with it, adjust to it, and even depend on it.
-Krutika Mali
No comments:
Post a Comment